Swaback versus the flat-earthers

by John Washington on December 7, 2016

The Voice of Korte put out an email this morning with a tangential nod toward the taxpayer-funded folly of Scottsdale Desert Discovery Center promoter/designer, Vern Swaback.

This week’s best sound bite comes from Vern Swaback, whose firm Swaback Partners [architecture firm], is working on the design of the Desert Discovery Center.

“There may very well be merit in the commitment to keep Scottsdale special, but if this quest fails to acknowledge the exceptional, it will do more harm than good. The simple reality is that each and every decision is either on the side of growth and renewal or death and decline.”

This quote was lifted from an AZ Central “My Turn” letter by Swaback that was dated December 6, 2016.

Ironically, this letter appears to have been largely recycled from when it was originally published in the Republic back in August. Carrie Watters at the Republic, the bane of mere peasants who want to get their opinions in print, must have let this letter from the Dark Side slip through the cracks.

You can read my point-by-point rebuttal of Swaback’s recycled hash in my previous writing on the subject.

I will note one item here that I didn’t previously address. Again quoting Swaback:

Speaking of Taliesin West, it is quite doubtful this global treasure could have ever been approved by today’s codes and ordinances. A host of exceptions had to be made for Frank Lloyd Wright’s winter home to become part of Scottsdale when the city incorporated.

Clearly Vern’s memory ain’t what it used to be. Taliesin West was established in 1937. The City of Scottsdale was incorporated fourteen years later in 1951. The area around Taliesin wasn’t annexed into Scottsdale until the 1980s.

In a second irony, I happened to take a tour at Taliesin West this past weekend; something I haven’t done in many years. It is to Taliesin West that Swaback claims to have been invited as Wright’s “youngest apprentice” [Green Building and Design Magazine].

During the tour there was a lot of talk of the pristine desert that motivated Wright to locate there. There was NO mention of Scottsdale’s adjacent McDowell Sonoran Preserve–the largest urban nature reserve in the country–nor the highly controversial Desert Discovery Center commercialization proposal for which Vern Swaback has been paid a million dollars to “study.”

Which leads me to a third irony. Also quoting from the above-referenced GBD article, Swaback says:

Wright’s idea of luxury wasn’t anything that money alone could buy.

Swaback wants to label anyone who opposes his grand ideas as Luddites. Yet he ignores the fact that almost all of us want only for our city staffers and elected officials to follow the growth policies enshrined in our citizen-ratified Scottsdale General Plan…NOT to stop growth altogether.

Swaback also fails to note that–unlike Swaback–none of his opponents make money from their efforts to “keep Scottsdale special.”

{ 4 comments }

Photo of the Day: Taliesin Doorway

by John Washington on December 5, 2016

Doorway, or a portal between spaces? At Frank Lloyd Wright’s Scottsdale winter camp, Taliesin West. Doorway at Taliesin West

{ 0 comments }

My Turn: Scottsdale Desert Discovery Center workshop was a publicity stunt

December 2, 2016

I attended the Nov. 30 Desert Discovery Center Public Workshop with an open mind and cautious optimism only to be discouraged and thoroughly insulted by the city of Scottsdale’s thinly disguised demonstration of desiring public input into this project. It was nothing more than a poorly staged PR stunt by the DDC Scottsdale and the […]

Read the full article →

Smith: the fiduciary responsibility of Scottsdale City Council | Scottsdale Independent

December 2, 2016

Sometimes, the gift clause test is not so much a measure of the legal facts of a case as it is a measure of council’s judgment. Other than council, and by delegation, city staff, Scottsdale citizens have no other advocate on their behalf. No, that’s not a quote from John Washington. It’s Scottsdale city councilman […]

Read the full article →

City tourism audit critical of Experience Scottsdale’s high pay, lack of focus on city

December 2, 2016

City leaders are preparing to renew their contract with Experience Scottsdale, which is in the last year of a five-year agreement. When the contract expires in June 2017, the city will likely have paid more than $42 million over the term. It’s worth noting that this is yet another example of a public/private partnership, wherein […]

Read the full article →

Extra lane on Loop 101 in Scottsdale won’t end traffic congestion

November 29, 2016

Scottsdale Transportation Director Paul Basha said…“We spent $100 million for 10 miles of freeway to stay congested. It (Loop 101) was an ‘F’ before, and it’s still going to be an ‘F’,” Basha said. “We spent $100 million for 10 miles of freeway to stay congested.” He does go on to say: Simply adding more […]

Read the full article →

Millennial Intelligence

November 28, 2016

Someone get a copy of this to Mayor Jim Lane and the Scottsdale City Council, quick! They are basing all their zoning decisions lately on what Millennials “want” and “need.” [Thanks, Jim DelRae]

Read the full article →

Donald Trump’s Case for ‘Honest Graft’ – The Atlantic

November 25, 2016

http://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2016/11/donald-trumps-case-for-honest-graft/508706/?google_editors_picks=true

Read the full article →

Glendale’s Pro Sports Bill May Hit $21 Million This Year | KJZZ

November 21, 2016

“I don’t know to say if it’s an equal value,” [Glendale city manager Kevin] Phelps said. “But I think it certainly presents a compelling case to be in that market.” If you don’t KNOW that you are getting your money’s worth, then there is nothing “compelling” about such a case. This uncharacteristically disjointed article by […]

Read the full article →

NIMBY Rose

November 16, 2016

I got a good chuckle out of reading this Tweet from Jason Rose, campaign PR manager for Scottsdale mayor Jim Lane. Jason and his lawyer-wife Jordan have advocated for, and profited nicely from dozens of high-density housing projects in Scottsdale. Jason is always keen to remind everyone during the course of his developer advocacy that […]

Read the full article →