
I don’t post here on the old blog very often, as social media (evil as it is) has broader circulation with less effort (See https://www.facebook.com/ScottsdaleCitizen/). I wish I had more time and resources to devote to Scottsdale issues, especially with the sad state of what remains of our local media. I’ve just got too many other irons in the fire.
So, if you are coming here, it’s likely because of my comment in the ballot pamphlet for Scottsdale’s upcoming city election:
Prop 400 is a SCAM. Vote NO!
1. Everything that the ballot language says this new tax will fund (maintenance and public safety services for parks and the Preserve), should have been budgeted out of existing tax revenue when acquisitions were first approved. Where did that money go?
2. If there are real shortfalls in funding, it is due solely to the council’s abandonment of fiscal responsibility for existing taxpayer funds. Why give them more tax money to waste?
3. The ballot language is so vague that this new tax money can and will be used for just about anything. The city has a long and proven history of misleading ballot measures AND of massive cost overruns due to negligent contract management after funding is approved.
4. 30 years?!!! Ridiculous!
John Washington, www.ScottsdaleCitizen.com
The ballot language (which forms the entirety of the restrictions upon the use of the proposed new tax revenue, regardless of any other propaganda you may have read) is:
A “YES” vote shall have the effect of authorizing the City to replace and reduce the current 0.20% transaction privilege and use tax rate, expiring in 2025, to 0.15%, for 30 years, effective July 1, 2025, for the sole purpose of: 1) improvements and maintenance for Citywide Parks and Recreational Facilities; 2) maintenance and protection for the McDowell Sonoran Preserve; and 3) increased Police and Fire resources related to Citywide Parks and the Preserve, with all being more specifically determined by City ordinance.
A “NO” vote shall have the effect of denying the City the authority to replace and reduce the current 0.20% transaction privilege and use tax rate, expiring in 2025, to 0.15%, for 30 years, effective July 1, 2025, for the sole purpose of: 1) improvements and maintenance for Citywide Parks and Recreational Facilities; 2) maintenance and protection for the McDowell Sonoran Preserve; and 3) increased Police and Fire resources related to Citywide Parks and the Preserve.
Probably the most important part of this language is the last clause in the “yes” paragraph:
“…with all being more specifically determined by City ordinance.”
So, we should just trust Mayor Ortega, the council, and city staff (who all just got big raises) with NEW tax money to cover maintenance shortfalls for which they SHOULD have previously budgeted? AND we should trust them to spend it ONLY on parks and the Preserve?
Not even a year has passed since we found out about massive cost overruns in questionable improvements to the Civic Center Mall area, caused by systemic failures in contracting and in contract management. So, no, I don’t trust them. Neither should you.
You may have heard about the Goldwater Institute’s lawsuit to block Prop 490 from going to the ballot. I listened to the Appeals Court arguments about the misleading nature of the language (“new” tax vs “replacing” the old one, etc). Frankly, the Goldwater Institute doesn’t impress me. They chose to sit on the sidelines while former mayor Jim Lane (the ostensible plaintiff in the current lawsuit) led the council to giving away millions of dollars to the PGA, the NFL, the NBA, Phil Mickelson, and several other entities who clearly have a lot more money than Scottsdale’s taxpayers. Further, Goldwater has a long history of suing institutions led by Democrats, and almost never Republicans (full disclosure: I am a registered Republican, though I’m not sure what that means anymore).
Goldwater’s arguments and the City’s at the Appeals Court were a mess. The level of confusion among the justices AND the lawyers clearly indicates that this proposition is half-baked, at best.
Goldwater didn’t spend any time within their arguments on the subject of fiscal responsibility. Maybe that’s because their darling Jimmie Lane didn’t either.
I used to think that fiscal responsibility was one of the main tenants of the Republican Party. Not so much anymore, I guess. Sad.